Mail Icon Facebook Icon Twitter Icon Share
NEWS & EVENTS Subscribe to rss news feed  

The welcome news from the Allegheny County Health Department last Friday that the Liberty monitor met the annual and daily federal air-quality standard in 2013 for fine particulate matter is a breath of fresh air. It marks a step forward in the long-term undertaking to move our region from the bottom to the top ranks nationally in air quality ratings.


We at the Breathe Project intend to use this momentum to redouble our efforts to achieve clean, healthy air for everyone in the Pittsburgh region. We realize that despite this important gain, there is still a lot of work yet to do. The race to win consistently clean air is a marathon, not a sprint—and there are many challenging, uphill miles left to cover.


The annual average in 2013 at the Liberty monitor was 12 micrograms per cubic meter, just meeting the annual PM2.5 standard set in 2012 by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The 24-hour PM2.5 average of 31.1 micrograms per cubic meter at Liberty fell below the EPA standard of 35 micrograms per cubic meter set in 2006. However, these data alone are insufficient to begin the celebration.


More data needed


It will take three consecutive years of monitoring data at or below the PM2.5 limits in order for EPA to formally declare that we are in “attainment” of the air quality standards. The point of requiring three years of data is to help distinguish between genuine, long-term air quality improvement and an aberration.


To reach attainment, the Liberty monitor must have readings below the standard for the next two years; already in 2014, there have been several days when air quality in the Liberty/Clairton area entered the “orange” and “red” zones, with dangerously high fine particle pollution levels.


On those days, we have received air quality complaints at the Breathe Project from as far away as the East End and the South Hills. As mobile monitoring data from Carnegie Mellon University researchers confirms, what’s in the air we breathe in the Mon Valley doesn’t just stay in the Mon Valley.


Particles aren’t the only problem


There’s no doubt that fine particulate pollution poses a significant health threat to Pittsburgh-area residents, contributing to heart attack, stroke, lung disease, asthma, adverse birth outcomes—and even premature death. But Allegheny County is plagued with a host of other air pollution problems, too:


= Allegheny County cancer risk from air toxics ranks in the top 2 percent in the United States, according to a 2013 report from the University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health’s Center for Healthy Environments and Communities. Air toxics are a class of pollutants known or suspected to cause cancer or other serious health effects, such as reproductive effects or birth defects. There are more than 200 Census tracts in southwestern Pennsylvania with a point source cancer risk over 10 in a million (EPA uses a threshold level of “one-in-a-million” probability of lifetime cancer risk above which it deems to be unacceptable or cause for concern). Industries in the Liberty/Clairton area are a major source of air toxics in our region.


= The county is in nonattainment for both the 1997 8-hour ozone standard (0.08 ppm) and the 2008 8-hour ozone standard (0.075 ppm). Ozone—or “smog”—is harmful to breathe and low levels can be deadly.


= Allegheny County is one of just 38 counties nationwide in nonattainment for the 2010 sulfur dioxide (SO2) standard; SO2 is linked with a number of adverse respiratory effects, and studies show a connection between short-term exposure and increased visits to emergency departments and hospital admissions, particularly in children, the elderly, and asthmatics. In the Liberty/Clairton area, levels of SO2 exceed the federal limit by almost double.


Monitors don’t tell us enough


Monitoring networks are designed to demonstrate attainment of federal air quality standards, and our region’s topography may frustrate the ability to accurately determine air quality for all locations, according to a 2011 report by the Boston-based Clean Air Task Force.


Our monitors are located in a small number of strategically chosen sites across the county. But anyone who has navigated the hilly terrain of Pittsburgh knows that our local topography is complex, which differentially impacts our air quality; in general, people living in river valleys that trap emissions tend to have greater exposures to air pollution than people on the tops of hills.


Exposures also vary depending on proximity to local industrial sources, such as power plants or coke plants, and transportation sources, such as highways or heavily trafficked areas like Downtown. Your personal health risk from air pollution also depends on “hyper-local” sources, such as woodstoves and fireplaces.


In other words, the concentrations recorded by our network of air quality monitors are unlikely to be fully representative of the levels of pollution to which the population are actually exposed—especially for people living in hotspot areas.


We deserve better than “moderate”


According to an analysis by the Clean Air Task Force, the Pittsburgh area experienced 239 days in 2013 when the EPA said our air quality was not rated “good.”  On these days (representing more than 65 percent of the year), we were told that our health risk from air pollution ranged from “moderate” to “unhealthy.”


Speaking last May at The Air We Breathe conference held Downtown on World Asthma Day, world-renowned environmental epidemiologist Joel Schwartz of Harvard School of Public Health noted that there is no evidence for a threshold below which air pollution has no health effects. That means that even “moderate” levels of pollution can have very serious—and potentially deadly—impacts on our health.


If we measured Pittsburgh’s air quality against more stringent World Health Organization (WHO) standards—and even the recommendations of EPA’s own Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee of scientists who provides regulatory advice—we would have even more days each year recognized as “unhealthy.”


We deserve clean, healthy air every day—not just 35 percent of the time.


Most Livable City?


While there’s no doubt the 2013 monitor data in Liberty is welcome news, it’s important to keep this “milestone” in perspective, looking at where we stand today relative to other American cities as a baseline.


Just how far behind is Pittsburgh?


Our air ranks in the dirtiest 10 percent of 338 urban areas for average annual particle pollution based on data from 2010-2012, according to a recent analysis by Clean Air Task Force.


It’s not just a problem in the Liberty/Clairton area. Nine out of 10 monitored areas in Allegheny County rank in the worst third in the nation for particle pollution. The monitor in North Braddock was still over the federal limit of 12 micrograms per cubic meter from 2010-2012 and didn’t meet the older annual standard of 15 micrograms per cubic meter until 2007-2009.


And we aren’t improving as quickly as other urban areas.


Based on 2010-2012 monitoring data, Allegheny County was one of just 53 counties out of 519 nationwide (10 percent) with valid monitoring data that failed to meet the 2012 annual fine particle health standard of 12 micrograms per cubic meter, according to EPA. More than half of these 519 counties had already met–or fallen below–that standard a full decade earlier. Moreover, 90 percent of the counties in violation of the older annual standard (15 micrograms per cubic meter) came into compliance before Allegheny County finally did in 2009-2011.


It’s time to stop comparing Pittsburgh to Pittsburgh 200 years ago—or comparing Pittsburgh to our own incremental pace of present-day improvement.


We must instead compare Pittsburgh to other modern cities in the U.S.—and even globally— that are competing with us for the most talented employees and the best companies. We must compare Pittsburgh to the ideal Pittsburgh we all envision for our great city—a city where the air is clean and safe every day and doesn’t jeopardize the health and future of our children with every breath.

Comments (1)

  1. Robert Falco says:

    Excellent Blog. Is the blogger aware that using ethanol fuel in vehicles will reduce particles in their exhaust to 1/7th of gasoline’s output (the reduction using E30 is almost as great as using E85). Getting more Flex Fueled vehicles on the road and getting more Blender pumps at service stations can make a big contribution to reducing particulates — and ozone. Flex Fueled vehicles don’t cost more, but installing Blender pumps will need community cooperation, USDA and State aid.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

March 26, 2017
Breathless: An Air Quality Expo Breathless – an Air Quality Expo   “Breathless – an Air Quality Expo” is a fun and free event where your entire family can learn about air pollution in the region, and learn how to reduce it so that we … Learn More
March 11, 2017
Creatives for Climate Workshop The second “Creatives for Climate Workshop” will be held on March 11th   Come explore climate solutions and create new ways to deal with climate change. Network and brainstorm with experts and peers alike. Get hands-on experiences exploring climate change … Learn More
December 8, 2016
Links Between Cancer and Early Life Exposures to Environmental Pollutants A Webinar on the Latest Science, and its Implications for Health Professionals   Accreditation: Approved for 1.0 AMA PRA Category 1 CreditTM Thursday, December 8th, 12:15 -1:15 pm, Eastern Standard Time   REGISTER FOR WEBINAR AT:   While pediatric … Learn More
November 19, 2016
Free artist talk with Andrea Polli – “Energy Flow” Join Carnegie Museum of Art’s Hillman Photography Initiative on November 19th at 1:30pm for a free artist talk with Andrea Polli, one of the Initiative’s contributing artists. Andrea is launching ‘Energy Flow,’ a large-scale public light artwork and wind power … Learn More
September 10, 2016
Go Green Festival plus Electric Car Show & Cruise A FREE Event Sponsored by Marcellus Outreach Butler, in cooperation with National Drive Electric Week and Beaver County Marcellus Awareness Committee   September 10, 2016 11 am – 5 pm   Kohl’s lower lot at Cranberry Commons (Rt. 228), Cranberry … Learn More
July 29, 2016
2016-2017 Green Workplace Challenge – Workshop Are you interested in competing in 2016-2017 Pittsburgh Green Workplace Challenge (GWC) but want to learn more before signing up by the Aug. 31 deadline? Are you signed up for the Challenge and ready to get ahead of the competition? … Learn More
June 16, 2016
Kickoff Celebration for the 2016-2017 Pittsburgh Green Workplace Challenge Commit to making the Pittsburgh region a better place to live, work, and play! Sign up for this year’s Pittsburgh Green Workplace Challenge (GWC) and attend the kickoff celebration on June 16!  All are invited to attend the kickoff, regardless … Learn More
May 12, 2016
FracTracker Lease Map Workshop as part of PF/PCA Exhibition FracTracker Alliance invites southwest PA residents to learn more about the first ever online, searchable map of oil and gas leases in Allegheny County, PA. FracTracker is holding a public workshop at the PCA galleries on May 12th to demonstrate … Learn More
See all events
latest on facebook
  • Breathe Project

    Sunday, March 26 at 2 PM - 6 PM
    282 St Clair Ave, Clairton, PA 15025-1738, United States


    Clean Water Action - Pennsylvania

    Mar 10th 11:10am • No Comments

    Please join us for the second "Creatives for Climate Workshop" on March 11th!

    Come explore climate solutions and create new ways to deal with climate change. Network and brainstorm with experts and peers alike. Get hands-on experiences exploring climate change and solutions.

    9:00 AM - 3:30 PM
    To be held at Repair The World: Pittsburgh
    Tickets $10 - Register by 3/6

    Greater Pittsburgh Arts Council
    Pittsburgh Filmmakers
    Carnegie Museum of Natural History

    Creatives for Climate Workshop

    Mar 5th 10:09pm • No Comments

    Please join us for the second "Creatives for Climate Workshop" on March 11th!

    Come explore climate solutions and create new ways to deal with climate change. Network and brainstorm with experts and peers alike. Get hands-on experiences exploring climate change and solutions.

    9:00 AM - 3:30 PM
    To be held at Repair The World: Pittsburgh
    Tickets $10 - Register by 3/6

    Greater Pittsburgh Arts Council
    Pittsburgh Filmmakers
    Carnegie Museum of Natural History

    Creatives for Climate Workshop

    Mar 1st 10:09am • No Comments

    Breathe Project shared Speck Sensor's post.

    Speck Sensor

    "Yards away sits an elementary school, where students and teachers breathe air tainted by tailpipes" #airquality

    Feb 21st 12:18pm • No Comments

    Breathe Project shared Speck Sensor's post.

    Speck Sensor

    See the 2017 State of Global Air Report highlighting #airquality and #health in all countries! #data #trends

    Feb 16th 2:09pm • No Comments

  • Press Contact
  • The Heinz Endowments
    Linda Braund, Communications Manager
    Phone: 412.338.2636
  • JOIN OUR COALITION Be part of the growing movement for clean air in the Pittsburgh region.
    Thank you for your support! Look for our updates in your email box. Please share this initiative with others who would be interested in joining as well:
    Today's Air Quality Forecast:
    Tomorrow's Forecast:
    Learn More About AQI >
    © Breathe Project 2014. All Rights Reserved.
    Terms of Service
    Privacy Policy
    Learn More