Mail Icon Facebook Icon Twitter Icon Share
NEWS & EVENTS Subscribe to rss news feed  

Tuesday, May 17, 2016
MEDIA CONTACT: Lou Takacs, Communications Director
412-350-4157, Louis.Takacs@AlleghenyCounty.US

 

(Pittsburgh) May 17, 2016    An audit by Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner indicates that the use of negotiated settlements known as consent decrees has failed to result in major air pollution sources coming into compliance with regulations. Rather than compelling significant reductions in emissions, these agreements have allowed the operators of polluting facilities to pay agreed-upon penalties while they continue to pollute at non-compliant levels.

 

“Instead of bringing harmful emissions to within regulatory limits and realizing the benefits such reductions would bring to the health of Allegheny County residents, major polluters have essentially been allowed to write their own ticket and continue to pollute,” Wagner said. “When companies consider fines simply part of the cost of doing business, of course their performance does not improve.”

 

Currently, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) designates at least part of Allegheny County as in non-attainment for three of six criteria pollutants: ozone, fine particulate matter, and sulfur dioxide. In 2013, Pittsburgh ranked below a dozen other benchmark metropolitan areas in both ozone and fine particulate matter measurements, according to EPA.

 

“If we are truly to leave behind the popular perception of Pittsburgh as the ‘smoky city’ and make our region the ‘most livable’ for all of our residents, we must work to make the facts match the rhetoric,” Wagner said.

 

The audit determined that understaffing in the Allegheny County Health Department’s (ACHD) Air Quality program has likely promoted the use of consent decrees rather than pursuing litigation which could have succeeded in reducing pollution levels. ACHD has generally had only one attorney on staff to negotiate and litigate air quality non-compliance, though a second attorney was recently hired.

 

For violations which have not been subject to consent agreements, the audit found that while federal regulations allow for increasing fines for repeat non-compliance up to a $25,000 per day maximum, ACHD has not fully employed this tool to compel reductions, leaving fines below the maximum penalty even as violations continue.

 

“If the rules continue to be broken after one punishment, then more serious penalties are warranted. Children are held to this standard, but not corporations? It’s time for the Health Department to get serious about companies that persist in breaking the law,” Wagner said.

 

The audit also found that a lack of adequate technological, organizational and human resources within the Air Quality Program resulted in significant backlogs in permit applications. A backlog of more than 200 initial or renewal permit applications existed, and 18 pollution sources were in operation based on installation permits without ever even applying for an operating permit. One facility was operating with its installation permit pending since 2009.

 

“While enforcement is a paramount duty of the Air Quality program, it also has a responsibility to industry to provide certainty and a stable regulatory environment. It is failing in this respect when permits are not issued for months or years on end,” Wagner said. “While these delays are not preventing companies from setting up shop and operating, they do send a poor message to manufacturers which may consider locating in Allegheny County.”

 

The ACHD’s current program management software is unable to even produce a list of all outstanding applications. This software also failed to generate bills for more than $7,000 in administrative fees which should have been collected by ACHD during 2014.

 

The audit also found that Air Quality program enforcement staff does not adequately document its evaluations of reports submitted by pollution sources so that verification may occur by management or interested outside parties.

 

“I believe firmly in ‘trust but verify.’ A signature on a form doesn’t tell me anything about what my children are breathing. The public needs to know how submissions from polluters are evaluated so that there can be confidence that the information we have is accurate,” Wagner said.

 

Despite available financial resources, the ACHD has not hired new monitoring staff until longstanding employees have retired or otherwise left their positions, preventing on-the-job training by experienced staff and the continuity of institutional knowledge. Furthermore, once vacancies have occurred they have often not been filled quickly.

 

“While there are always financial and practical limitations on government, I believe as an elected official and as a mother that investments in ensuring the quality of our air are essential, and that making improvements in monitoring should be a foremost priority for the County,” Wagner said.

 

The full Analysis of the Allegheny County Health Department’s Air Quality Program For the Period January 1, 2014 through December 31, 2014 can be viewed here.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

events
March 26, 2017
Breathless: An Air Quality Expo Breathless – an Air Quality Expo   “Breathless – an Air Quality Expo” is a fun and free event where your entire family can learn about air pollution in the region, and learn how to reduce it so that we … Learn More
March 11, 2017
Creatives for Climate Workshop The second “Creatives for Climate Workshop” will be held on March 11th   Come explore climate solutions and create new ways to deal with climate change. Network and brainstorm with experts and peers alike. Get hands-on experiences exploring climate change … Learn More
December 8, 2016
Links Between Cancer and Early Life Exposures to Environmental Pollutants A Webinar on the Latest Science, and its Implications for Health Professionals   Accreditation: Approved for 1.0 AMA PRA Category 1 CreditTM Thursday, December 8th, 12:15 -1:15 pm, Eastern Standard Time   REGISTER FOR WEBINAR AT: http://bit.ly/cancerlinkswebinar   While pediatric … Learn More
November 19, 2016
Free artist talk with Andrea Polli – “Energy Flow” Join Carnegie Museum of Art’s Hillman Photography Initiative on November 19th at 1:30pm for a free artist talk with Andrea Polli, one of the Initiative’s contributing artists. Andrea is launching ‘Energy Flow,’ a large-scale public light artwork and wind power … Learn More
September 10, 2016
Go Green Festival plus Electric Car Show & Cruise A FREE Event Sponsored by Marcellus Outreach Butler, in cooperation with National Drive Electric Week and Beaver County Marcellus Awareness Committee   September 10, 2016 11 am – 5 pm   Kohl’s lower lot at Cranberry Commons (Rt. 228), Cranberry … Learn More
July 29, 2016
2016-2017 Green Workplace Challenge – Workshop Are you interested in competing in 2016-2017 Pittsburgh Green Workplace Challenge (GWC) but want to learn more before signing up by the Aug. 31 deadline? Are you signed up for the Challenge and ready to get ahead of the competition? … Learn More
June 16, 2016
Kickoff Celebration for the 2016-2017 Pittsburgh Green Workplace Challenge Commit to making the Pittsburgh region a better place to live, work, and play! Sign up for this year’s Pittsburgh Green Workplace Challenge (GWC) and attend the kickoff celebration on June 16!  All are invited to attend the kickoff, regardless … Learn More
May 12, 2016
FracTracker Lease Map Workshop as part of PF/PCA Exhibition FracTracker Alliance invites southwest PA residents to learn more about the first ever online, searchable map of oil and gas leases in Allegheny County, PA. FracTracker is holding a public workshop at the PCA galleries on May 12th to demonstrate … Learn More
See all events
latest on facebook
  • Breathe Project

    Sunday, March 26 at 2 PM - 6 PM
    282 St Clair Ave, Clairton, PA 15025-1738, United States

    Tickets: http://org.salsalabs.com/o/2155/p/salsa/event/common/public/?event_KEY=99579

    Clean Water Action - Pennsylvania

    Mar 10th 11:10am • No Comments

    Please join us for the second "Creatives for Climate Workshop" on March 11th!

    Come explore climate solutions and create new ways to deal with climate change. Network and brainstorm with experts and peers alike. Get hands-on experiences exploring climate change and solutions.

    9:00 AM - 3:30 PM
    To be held at Repair The World: Pittsburgh
    Tickets $10 - Register by 3/6 http://bit.ly/2lhvujJ

    Greater Pittsburgh Arts Council
    Pittsburgh Filmmakers
    Carnegie Museum of Natural History

    Creatives for Climate Workshop

    eventbrite.com

    Mar 5th 10:09pm • No Comments

    Please join us for the second "Creatives for Climate Workshop" on March 11th!

    Come explore climate solutions and create new ways to deal with climate change. Network and brainstorm with experts and peers alike. Get hands-on experiences exploring climate change and solutions.

    9:00 AM - 3:30 PM
    To be held at Repair The World: Pittsburgh
    Tickets $10 - Register by 3/6 http://bit.ly/2lhvujJ

    Greater Pittsburgh Arts Council
    Pittsburgh Filmmakers
    Carnegie Museum of Natural History

    Creatives for Climate Workshop

    eventbrite.com

    Mar 1st 10:09am • No Comments

    Breathe Project shared Speck Sensor's post.

    Speck Sensor

    "Yards away sits an elementary school, where students and teachers breathe air tainted by tailpipes" #airquality http://ow.ly/q1DK309bnIP

    Feb 21st 12:18pm • No Comments

    Breathe Project shared Speck Sensor's post.

    Speck Sensor

    See the 2017 State of Global Air Report highlighting #airquality and #health in all countries! http://ow.ly/EZOf3092uwU #data #trends

    Feb 16th 2:09pm • No Comments

  • Press Contact
  • The Heinz Endowments
    Linda Braund, Communications Manager
    Phone: 412.338.2636
    Email: lbraund@heinz.org
  • JOIN OUR COALITION Be part of the growing movement for clean air in the Pittsburgh region.
    Thank you for your support! Look for our updates in your email box. Please share this initiative with others who would be interested in joining as well:
    CONNECT WITH US
    Today's Air Quality Forecast:
    Good
    Tomorrow's Forecast:
    Good
    Learn More About AQI >
    CONTACT
    © Breathe Project 2014. All Rights Reserved.
    Terms of Service
    Privacy Policy
    Learn More